The Builder's Brief / Issue #17
$5 or $45 for the same wine?
The study that explains why your price is too low and the four questions that fix that number this week
Builder's Brief
Issue 17 | October 26, 2026
1. You Priced It Against Your Own Wallet
Twenty people drank the same wine twice and liked it more when the label said $45 instead of $5.
Researchers at Caltech and Stanford, led by Hilke Plassmann, published that result in 2008. Test subjects that tasted wines marked at different prices while lying in a scanner reported more pleasure from the expensive-looking label, and showed more activity in the part of the brain that encodes how good an experience actually feels. Their ratings of taste intensity did not change at all, and when the same people drank the same wines without labels in a later session, they scored them identically. By the end of this you will have a new number and a way to test it on three people.
The price was not describing the wine to them. It was changing the experience of drinking it, which is the half of pricing that most student founders set their numbers as though it did not exist.
Here is the mistake almost everyone on this campus makes, and it is an honest one. You set your price by quietly imagining yourself paying it, and since you have eleven dollars in checking until Friday and fifteen dollars a month feels like real money, fifteen dollars a month is the number that ends up on the pricing page. The office manager you are selling to probably renewed a four hundred dollar scheduling tool last month without opening the invoice because that number is smaller than the problem it removes and smaller than an hour of anybody's salary.
Alex Hormozi makes a version of this argument from the operator's side in $100M offers, where the claim is that a higher price raises both perceived value and the buyer's own commitment to the outcome. In any business where the customer has to do something to get the result, that second effect is the one that pays you back, because the client who paid properly shows up to the call and the client who paid fifteen dollars forgets they ever bought it.
So stop anchoring the number on what the thing cost you to build, which your buyer cannot see and has no reason to care about, and anchor it instead on what the problem is already costing them every month. Four questions get you there. Here they are:
• What does this problem cost them right now, in hours per week or dollars per month?
• What do they already pay for the nearest alternative, including the manual one where somebody does it by hand on Sunday night?
• What would they have to stop buying in order to start paying you?
• If you doubled the number, who exactly says no, and were they a customer you wanted?
The last question is the one worth sitting with for a minute, because the honest answer is usually that the people who walk away at double the price are the same people emailing you at midnight about a feature nobody else has ever asked for.
Your number is a hypothesis; it’s not a promise you made to the universe, so quote the new one to the next three people you speak to and leave everybody who already signed up exactly where they are. Tell them you are doing that, since grandfathering costs you nothing in revenue you were ever going to collect and buys real goodwill from the only customers you currently have.
One small decision decides whether any of this survives contact with a real conversation. I would suggest: when you say the number, say it and then stop talking. The silence after a price is unbearable for about four seconds, and the reflex is to fill it by apologizing for the figure, volunteering a discount that nobody asked for or cares about, or quietly revising it downward before the other person has answered, which means everything you add after the number is a negotiation you opened against yourself.
Say the number and stop talking.
Written by Nishant Nair
2. Founder Opportunities
Elevate Ventures Student Venture Workshop Deadline: RSVP before Thursday, October 29
• Best for: Students turning an idea into a company. Validating a customer problem, finding cofounders and accessing capital, with founder and investor sessions. October 29, 1 to 4pm, networking hour until 6pm, at Elevate Ventures HQ in Indianapolis.
Apply: buildpurdue.org/events
SXSW EDU Launch Startup Competition Deadline: November 1, final entry ($100 fee)
• Best for: Education startups with a public site, real usage metrics and under $8M raised. Live pitch at SXSW EDU in Austin, March 2027.
Apply: sxswedu.com/competitions
Y Combinator, Winter 2027 batch Deadline: November 2, 8pm PT
• Best for: One week out. $500,000 on acceptance, batch runs January through March in San Francisco, decisions by December 11.
Apply: ycombinator.com/apply
Rice Business Plan Competition 2027 Deadline: applications open November 9
• Best for: Teams with at least one graduate student. Over $1,000,000 in prizes, finals at Rice April 8 to 10.
Apply: rbpc.rice.edu
Purdue Innovates Accelerator Deadline: December 20, 11:59pm EST
• Best for: Purdue-connected startups with traction. Three months, mentors and corporate intros, investment-based.
Apply: purdueinnovates.org/accelerator
Sources
Plassmann, O'Doherty, Shiv and Rangel, PNAS 2008 | Hilke Plassmann, INSEAD | Alex Hormozi, $100M Offers | Elevate Ventures event page
buildpurdue
West Lafayette, Indiana
Was this useful?
Your rating shapes what we publish next.